Skip to content
Made in the UKScan my site freeFree scan

Area 4 of 10 in the UltimateSEO Framework v4.3

Quality and evidence

Whether a page completes the task and can be trusted. It covers task completion, length without fixed word counts, effort and skill, defensible value, verified claims and matching evidence, facts with units and dates, honest freshness, first-party data, methodology, first-hand experience, fair comparisons, working tools, case studies and AI-assisted production. 4 of the 15 are hard gates: a confirmed FAIL on any of them stops publication until it is fixed. The scan gives a partial signal for 4 and needs your evidence for 11.

Controls
15
Hard gates
4
Automated checks
0

Every Quality and evidence control, with priority, hard gates and how it is checked

Automated the scan can produce pass or fail evidence on its own. Partly automated the crawl gives a signal, a person decides. Needs your evidence Search Console, logs, business facts or reviews are required; the state stays UNKNOWN until you supply them.

IDControlPriorityChecked by
Q-01Complete the user taskP1Partly automated
Q-02Do not impose fixed word counts or keyword densityP2Needs your evidence
Q-03Demonstrate appropriate effort and skill Hard gateP0Partly automated
Q-04Add defensible value rather than commodity filler Hard gateP0Needs your evidence
Q-05Verify consequential factual claims before publication Hard gateP0Needs your evidence
Q-06Match evidence to the precise claim Hard gateP0Needs your evidence
Q-07Keep units, conditions, time and geography attached to factsP1Partly automated
Q-08Use honest content freshnessP1Partly automated
Q-09Publish first-party data with provenance and privacy controlsP1Needs your evidence
Q-10Explain research and benchmark methodologyP1Needs your evidence
Q-11Substantiate first-hand experienceP1Needs your evidence
Q-12Make comparisons fair and constraint-specificP1Needs your evidence
Q-13Provide real calculators and decision toolsP1Needs your evidence
Q-14Build case studies with an evidence chainP1Needs your evidence
Q-15Apply the same quality standard to AI-assisted productionP1Needs your evidence

Back to the framework hub, or see how the publish gate uses these controls.